|                     |
|
ForceFed420a | Jan-17-06 06:42 AM |
Member since Oct 18th 2004
620 posts,
| |
|
#95815, "RE: Timing Belt Install Question"
In response to Reply # 11
|
Originally posted by DR1665Originally posted by ForceFed420a You mean with the Cylinder 1 (and 4) at TDC, you can spin the cams without hitting the pistons? I thought we had an interference motor, which would mean that you can't do that. Brian Well, Brian, he said that he had all the pistons halfway up/down. I would think that, so long as none of the pistons were truly at TDC, you could spin the cams all you wanted. I've honestly never even bothered to check this out. You're not turning anything that fast to begin with, and you'd feel it if you made contact, so I doubt any damage would occur beyond what you get from valves rolling into each other on the work bench.  This is just how I roll.
Brian (right?), I see what you're saying. Assuming the pistons are indeed halfway down, then yes, you certainly could turn the cams as much as you want. However, with the crank at TDC (aligned with the oil pump mark), then rotating the cams (360º) will cause them to hit the pistons. If he truly has it aligned on the crank, then it will truely be at TDC. That's how I interpreted the question.
Here's why I'm being kinda anal. I just had to work on my brother-in-law's Grand am (2.4). His crank sprocket broke and caused the piston/valve collision to bend the valves. I replaced the crank sprocket, timing chain and cleaned the oil pan, and we took it to a mechanic to take the head off and replace the valves (I ran out of time) He took it to the mechanic (who actually called me to talk about the motor) and the mechanic said that the valves were bent, but very slightly. He said it doesn't take much to bend a valve so it doesn't seat. In fact the pistons showed no signs of damage and the valves were just slightly bent.
Here's the kicker, the compression on 2 cylinders was zero.
My point in saying this is that I just went through what can happen if pistons hit valves, and with the cams snapping around like they do, I didn't want him to have a slightly bent valve and having to pull the head off.
Now granted, the motor was running when this happened. Could you do the same damage just turning it yourself? Probably not.
I hope this clarifies where I'm coming from.
BrianRed 97 Eclipse GS (420a) MTX Custom Garrett T3 Turbo system Megasquirt w/52 lb/hr injectors & a Walbro 255 Kicker/Alpine Audio (3 amps, 2 subs) 90 Cav 2.2 TBI auto (winter) <- yeah, it's fast
|
|
|
|