Welcome to the 2GNT Forum! Interested In Advertising with 2GNT?
Home | Site Background| Info&Specs| Mods & Tech Info | CAPS | Part Reviews | Donate | 2GNT Stickers |
Search Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend 2 Users in Chat
Top 2GNT Technical Handling/Suspension topic #16035
View in linear mode

Subject: "RE: Do adjustable strut bars really work? Ponderings and technical discussion" Previous topic | Next topic
SquidFeb-26-03 08:32 AM
Donating 2GNT member
927 posts,
Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author Click to view this author's profile Click to add this author to your buddy list
#16045, "RE: Do adjustable strut bars really work? Ponderings and technical discussion"
In response to In response to 2




          

From an engineering standpoint the weakest point of those no-name strutbars are the flanges that connect the bar to the mounting flange.

If you really want to stiffen up the chassis you would connect the strut towers using a triangulated member. In other words it would connect to the strut towers and then to one more point (3 points total). For a front strutbar I would have it connect to the firewall.



However if you are going to connect them using a single bar I would not weld the bar to the mounting flange but would use a pin or bolt that allows the bar to rotate relative to the mounting flange. If it is welded when the car flexes it will have a tendency to bend (red arrow) the bar. A thin narrow bar will not resist bending very well. On the other hand if the bar is allowed to rotate relative to the mounting flange the bar can’t be bent by the flexing of the chassis (the rotating motion won’t be transferred to the bar because the bar is free to rotate) and will instead be pushed on by the mounting flange (black arrow). The bar will do much better being compressed than being bent.



However I’m not saying that the Neuspeed bar is as bad or worse than a no-name bar only because I can’t vouch for the workmanship and sturdiness of the no-name bar and the Neuspeed looks like a very hefty piece of material.

-J

  

Report This Post to Admin Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote

Do adjustable strut bars really work? Ponderings and technical discussion [View all] , Mystic511, Feb-26-03 05:29 AM
  RE: Do adjustable strut bars really work? Ponderings and technical discussion, BlakeW5, Feb-26-03 06:01 AM, #1
RE: Do adjustable strut bars really work? Ponderings and technical discussion, juggalo, Feb-26-03 08:30 AM, #2
      RE: Do adjustable strut bars really work? Ponderings and technical discussion, Squid, Feb-26-03 08:32 AM #3
           RE: Do adjustable strut bars really work? Ponderings and technical discussion, BuckNutty, Feb-26-03 08:59 AM, #4
                RE: Do adjustable strut bars really work? Ponderings and technical discussion, Mystic511, Feb-26-03 10:58 AM, #5
                     RE: Do adjustable strut bars really work? Ponderings and technical discussion, juggalo, Feb-26-03 11:28 AM, #6
                     RE: Do adjustable strut bars really work? Ponderings and technical discussion, Squid, Feb-27-03 03:49 AM, #7
                          RE: Do adjustable strut bars really work? Ponderings and technical discussion, jerseystyle1, Feb-28-03 02:23 AM, #8
                               RE: Do adjustable strut bars really work? Ponderings and technical discussion, espilcEGS, Feb-28-03 12:42 PM, #9
                               RE: Do adjustable strut bars really work? Ponderings and technical discussion, jerseystyle1, Mar-01-03 01:23 AM, #10
                                    RE: Do adjustable strut bars really work? Ponderings and technical discussion, TeamMuRiX, Mar-04-03 01:19 AM, #11
                               RE: Do adjustable strut bars really work? Ponderings and technical discussion, Squid, Mar-04-03 03:58 AM, #12
                                    RE: Do adjustable strut bars really work? Ponderings and technical discussion, Hurricane_GS, Mar-05-03 03:38 PM, #13
                                         RE: Do adjustable strut bars really work? Ponderings and technical discussion, Squid, Mar-06-03 04:28 AM, #14
                                              RE: Do adjustable strut bars really work? Ponderings and technical discussion, Hurricane_GS, Mar-06-03 08:46 AM, #15
                                                   RE: Do adjustable strut bars really work? Ponderings and technical discussion, Teameclipse804, Mar-10-03 07:54 PM, #16
                                                        RE: Do adjustable strut bars really work? Ponderings and technical discussion, Squid, Mar-11-03 05:53 AM, #17
RE: Do adjustable strut bars really work? Ponderings and technical discussion, HadesOmega, Mar-12-03 10:49 AM, #18

Top 2GNT Technical Handling/Suspension topic #16035 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.2
Copyright 1997-2003 DCScripts.com

I generated this page in 0.034879207611084 seconds, executing 12 queries.