2GNT.com Forums - Viewing message - RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle)

Interested In Advertising with 2GNT?

Printer-friendly copy

Email this topic to a friend

0 Users in Chat

Top

2GNT Technical

Performance/Engine

Engine Management Systems & Controllers

topic #5700

View in linear mode

Subject: "RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle)"

Previous topic | Next topic

Tired2	Sep-05-13 08:13 PM
Member since Sep 23rd 2012 124 posts,

#5820, "RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle)"
In response to In response to 96

Gruff,

Would you mind posting your closed loop idle settings? Specifically I'm interested in seeing if your steps min, steps max, rpm closed, and rpm open somewhat matches mine.

Gains would be nice for comparison as well if you wouldn't mind.

After some playing tonight, I got idle working much better with open loop, and found at about 88 steps I get a pretty bad ~900 RPM idle. With it at 110 steps, I get around 1600rpm, so I used those values.

I need more time tuning the PID though. I think it is the fault of my P-Gain being too high, but when I burn the settings, rpm drops a bit, which sends steps up to like 115 from 94, and the RPM starts into the 2000s and I have to kill it. The next start will settle out, and loading up the motor by turning the wheel works decently well, but still drops a lot in RPM, which is why I jacked up the P gain in the first place.

Report This Post to Admin

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote

MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle) [View all] , RfOeCnKdOeNr, May-05-13 03:16 PM

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, May-05-13 03:17 PM, #1

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), SilvrEclips, May-07-13 05:55 PM, #2

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, May-07-13 07:12 PM, #3

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, May-07-13 07:16 PM, #4

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), SilvrEclips, May-08-13 07:54 AM, #5

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Gruff511, May-09-13 08:54 AM, #6

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, May-15-13 09:39 AM, #7

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, May-15-13 10:05 AM, #8

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, May-15-13 10:16 AM, #9

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, May-15-13 11:03 AM, #10

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, May-15-13 11:25 AM, #11

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, May-15-13 12:11 PM, #12

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, May-22-13 06:43 PM, #13

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, May-23-13 10:28 AM, #14

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, May-23-13 01:02 PM, #15

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Gruff511, May-23-13 01:19 PM, #16

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, May-23-13 03:16 PM, #17

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Jun-16-13 11:04 AM, #28

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Jun-10-13 08:33 AM, #18

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Jun-10-13 08:46 AM, #19

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Jun-10-13 08:50 AM, #20

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Jun-10-13 09:23 AM, #21

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Jun-10-13 12:51 PM, #22

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Jun-10-13 12:54 PM, #23

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Jun-10-13 01:17 PM, #24

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Jun-10-13 01:20 PM, #25

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Jun-11-13 08:34 AM, #26

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Jun-11-13 08:48 AM, #27

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Jun-17-13 09:42 AM, #32

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Jun-17-13 11:37 AM, #33

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Jun-17-13 11:40 AM, #34

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Jun-17-13 11:50 AM, #35

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Jun-16-13 06:57 PM, #29

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Jun-17-13 09:16 AM, #30

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Jun-17-13 09:22 AM, #31

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Jun-23-13 10:32 AM, #36

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Jun-23-13 08:13 PM, #37

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Jun-23-13 08:18 PM, #38

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Jun-24-13 06:08 AM, #39

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Jun-26-13 07:19 AM, #40

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Jun-26-13 08:27 AM, #41

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Jun-30-13 12:42 PM, #42

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Jun-30-13 12:58 PM, #43

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Jul-06-13 07:27 PM, #44

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Jul-08-13 11:30 AM, #45

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Gruff511, Jul-11-13 09:15 AM, #46

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Jul-16-13 05:32 PM, #47

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Jul-17-13 06:56 AM, #48

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Jul-17-13 08:33 AM, #49

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Jul-17-13 08:43 AM, #50

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Jul-17-13 11:12 AM, #51

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Jul-17-13 11:17 AM, #52

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Jul-17-13 11:32 AM, #53

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Jul-17-13 12:48 PM, #54

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Jul-21-13 05:28 PM, #55

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Aug-01-13 07:54 AM, #56

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Aug-01-13 08:07 AM, #57

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Aug-01-13 08:10 PM, #58

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Aug-01-13 10:55 PM, #60

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Aug-24-13 10:04 PM, #61

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Aug-26-13 06:47 AM, #62

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), SymTech Labs, Aug-01-13 08:32 PM, #59

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Aug-31-13 08:53 PM, #63

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Gruff511, Sep-01-13 11:53 AM, #64

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Sep-01-13 04:56 PM, #65

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Sep-02-13 07:30 AM, #66

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Sep-02-13 07:57 AM, #67

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Sep-02-13 08:00 AM, #68

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Gruff511, Sep-02-13 10:10 AM, #69

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Sep-02-13 11:53 AM, #70

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Sep-02-13 02:05 PM, #71

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Sep-02-13 02:31 PM, #72

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Sep-02-13 02:44 PM, #73

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Sep-02-13 02:47 PM, #74

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Sep-02-13 02:51 PM, #75

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Sep-02-13 03:58 PM, #76

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Gruff511, Sep-02-13 08:20 PM, #77

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Sep-02-13 08:36 PM, #79

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Gruff511, Sep-02-13 09:32 PM, #80

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Sep-02-13 08:27 PM, #78

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Gruff511, Sep-03-13 10:19 AM, #81

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Sep-03-13 11:12 AM, #82

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Gruff511, Sep-03-13 01:12 PM, #83

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Sep-03-13 01:25 PM, #84

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Sep-03-13 02:42 PM, #85

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Sep-03-13 05:48 PM, #86

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Sep-03-13 05:57 PM, #87

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Sep-03-13 06:07 PM, #88

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Gruff511, Sep-03-13 07:47 PM, #89

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Sep-03-13 08:09 PM, #90

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Gruff511, Sep-03-13 10:38 PM, #91

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Sep-04-13 06:43 AM, #92

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Sep-04-13 08:47 PM, #93

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Gruff511, Sep-04-13 09:35 PM, #94

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Sep-04-13 09:53 PM, #95

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Gruff511, Sep-04-13 10:15 PM, #96

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Sep-05-13 08:13 PM #97

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Gruff511, Sep-05-13 10:49 PM, #98

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Sep-07-13 08:31 AM, #99

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Sep-07-13 02:02 PM, #100

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Gruff511, Sep-07-13 03:23 PM, #101

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Sep-08-13 09:16 AM, #102

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Sep-08-13 03:47 PM, #103

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Sep-08-13 04:10 PM, #104

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Gruff511, Sep-08-13 09:13 PM, #105

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Sep-17-13 07:02 PM, #106

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Gruff511, Sep-18-13 01:14 AM, #107

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Sep-18-13 07:14 AM, #108

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Sep-18-13 10:44 AM, #109

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Sep-18-13 11:09 AM, #110

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Tired2, Sep-18-13 11:11 AM, #111

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Sep-18-13 11:17 AM, #112

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), RfOeCnKdOeNr, Sep-23-13 05:42 PM, #113

RE: MS2 - Stalling After Start (No Idle), Gruff511, Sep-27-13 08:29 PM, #114

Top

2GNT Technical

Performance/Engine

Engine Management Systems & Controllers

topic #5700

Previous topic | Next topic

Tweets by @2gnt

^{I generated this page in 0.021110057830811 seconds, executing 14 queries.}