Go back to previous topic
Forum nameTurbo/Nitrous Tech
Topic subjectBallbearing vs. 360 degree thrust bearing
Topic URLhttps://forums.2gnt.com/dcboard.php?az=show_topic&forum=i8&topic_id=93149
93149, Ballbearing vs. 360 degree thrust bearing
Posted by bzoss, Feb-04-06 04:59 AM
Like the thread says, what would be the major differences, and pro's and con's of each?
93163, RE: Ballbearing vs. 360 degree thrust bearing
Posted by Star Turbo Talon, Feb-04-06 01:58 PM
360 degree thrust bearing is behind the compressor wheel and is much better protection from side to side wear. Ball bearing are bearings on the shaft. They have separate functions.


Terry
93164, RE: Ballbearing vs. 360 degree thrust bearing
Posted by BumpinTalon, Feb-04-06 02:28 PM
apples to oranges, like star turbo talon said.

maybe you meant journal bearing vs. ball bearing?

ball bearings flow more, spool sooner, are more efficient, require less oil to lubricate

journal bearings are cheaper.

93168, RE: Ballbearing vs. 360 degree thrust bearing
Posted by Blizare, Feb-04-06 04:53 PM
Originally posted by BumpinTalon
ball bearings flow more, spool sooner, are more efficient, require less oil to lubricate


I just love the way my t28bb keeps spinning for a minute or so after shutting off the car :P



93175, RE: Ballbearing vs. 360 degree thrust bearing
Posted by bzoss, Feb-05-06 07:12 AM
what about price? who makes the ballbearings?
93176, RE: Ballbearing vs. 360 degree thrust bearing
Posted by slowmitsu, Feb-05-06 07:38 AM
Originally posted by bzoss
what about price? who makes the ballbearings?

Garrett for one and DBB turbo's are far more expensive than non DBB turbos.


This thread has "uneducated purchase" written all over it... :wary
93187, RE: Ballbearing vs. 360 degree thrust bearing
Posted by Star Turbo Talon, Feb-06-06 01:00 AM
Originally posted by slowmitsu
Originally posted by bzoss what about price? who makes the ballbearings?
Garrett for one and DBB turbo's are far more expensive than non DBB turbos. This thread has "uneducated purchase" written all over it... :wary


This is a very good question to ask here. Many people dont know the inner working of turbo's. I am willing to bet that you couldnt explain the actual physical different of a 360* thrust versus a standard thrust bearing.

Terry
93188, RE: Ballbearing vs. 360 degree thrust bearing
Posted by slowmitsu, Feb-06-06 01:34 AM
Originally posted by Star Turbo Talon
Originally posted by slowmitsu
Originally posted by bzoss what about price? who makes the ballbearings?
Garrett for one and DBB turbo's are far more expensive than non DBB turbos. This thread has "uneducated purchase" written all over it... :wary
This is a very good question to ask here. Many people dont know the inner working of turbo's. I am willing to bet that you couldnt explain the actual physical different of a 360* thrust versus a standard thrust bearing. Terry

The difference being that I know how to research a question.

Edit:
nvm
93201, RE: Ballbearing vs. 360 degree thrust bearing
Posted by bzoss, Feb-06-06 11:22 AM
so is it really worth the extra $1000 to upgrade to ballbearing?
Or... is the 360* thrust's spooling charactoristics to close to worry about dropin' the doah?
93402, RE: Ballbearing vs. 360 degree thrust bearing
Posted by Rax2, Feb-17-06 08:42 PM
Originally posted by bzoss
so is it really worth the extra $1000 to upgrade to ballbearing? Or... is the 360* thrust's spooling charactoristics to close to worry about dropin' the doah?


Like they said above, the 360* has nothing to do with the BB aspect.. It doesn't affect spool AFAIK.. There is a thrust spring that pushes the bearing and the thrust collar in the CHRA, This is the stuff that goes bad to give you end play on a turbo.. Typical turbos run a 270* (Pretty sure anyway) the 360* is an upgrade as more surface area contact means more likely of a chance that trust loading will be spread out equally on the shaft/turbine...

BB being worth the price is a matter of opinion. If you are going to stay under 15lbs, no.. If you are racing mainly on the interstate, no.. If you already are experiencing traction issues on your current turbo's spool time, no... If you want the fastest spool possible from a stop, sure.. if you want the most out of your turbo, sure..
93423, RE: Ballbearing vs. 360 degree thrust bearing
Posted by Star Turbo Talon, Feb-18-06 06:30 PM
Originally posted by Rax2
Originally posted by bzoss so is it really worth the extra $1000 to upgrade to ballbearing? Or... is the 360* thrust's spooling charactoristics to close to worry about dropin' the doah?
There is a thrust spring that pushes the bearing and the thrust collar in the CHRA,


Really? could you find a picture of this spring? I would really like to see one...........:rolleyes
93443, RE: Ballbearing vs. 360 degree thrust bearing
Posted by Rax2, Feb-20-06 06:28 AM
"Really? could you find a picture of this spring? I would really like to see one.......... "

You're in luck, well sort of.. I have a T3/T4 torn apart in the garage, but my camera battery is dead, and I'm too lazy to charge it.. So here's a crappy phone pic.. But if you've ever taken apart a turbo, you'll recognize it..


http://putfile.com/pic.php?pic=2/5012252611.jpg&s=x11
93444, RE: Ballbearing vs. 360 degree thrust bearing
Posted by Star Turbo Talon, Feb-20-06 08:00 AM
yes I have pulled apart a few turbo's. You said spring and i was think you trying to tell there was a coil spring in it. NVM my brainfart.