Hmm I think 2 tires should be half the price, so if you got V-rated 205/55/16 then it should be about 175 mounted and balanced. Probably at most 190 if they wanted to charge more because you only bought two. Some places charge a lot for mounting and balancing, so check it out. I would stick to new tires if you could just because I always like new things personally, and don't know if a used tire has been repaired before or if anything was wrong with it etc (like firestones for suv's).