Yea, I picked it up today and turns out thats what they meant. I wish I was a little more awake at the time of the call so I could have asked more as the car was JUST aligned and they decided to do all wheels again. They could have just done the front but whatever, thats why they are called satan I guess.

The bad thing is that the humming noise didn't even go away after this. The wiggle in the wheel did however so at least it's safe to drive. I'm just going to assume that the humming is just from the awkardly worn tires and keep my eye on the other wheel that hasn't been fixed.