Go back to previous topic
Forum namePerformance/Engine
Topic subjectKnock when started
Topic URLhttps://forums.2gnt.com/dcboard.php?az=show_topic&forum=i5&topic_id=95515
95515, Knock when started
Posted by Madoc05, Jan-04-06 05:44 AM
I have a 99 GS with a 420a short block and new internals. When i start the car up it has a knocking from the engine bay and then stops when it warms up. Anybody know what could be causing this
95516, RE: Knock when started
Posted by DarkOne, Jan-04-06 05:54 AM
Is it a knocking, or a grinding? Is it a pronounced knock, or is it somewhat subtle?
95517, RE: Knock when started
Posted by Madoc05, Jan-04-06 06:02 AM
It's more of a grinding, it sounds like it's coming from the transmission side.
95518, RE: Knock when started
Posted by DarkOne, Jan-04-06 06:04 AM
Just TOB noise, don't worry about it. They all do that at some point.
95519, RE: Knock when started
Posted by Blizare, Jan-04-06 06:05 AM
Did you replace any clutch components?
95520, RE: Knock when started
Posted by Madoc05, Jan-04-06 06:12 AM
yes i put a whole new tranmission in about 6000 miles ago
95532, RE: Knock when started
Posted by shazow1969, Jan-04-06 02:45 PM
What about the Clutch and Throw Out Bearing?? TOB will definately make some noise when cold, if it's bad that is.

-Kevin
95614, RE: Knock when started
Posted by sike, Jan-08-06 10:28 AM
IF it is the TOB, it will likely not make the noise when you press the clutch pedal. Try that. Did you rebuild with OEM pistons or forged pistons? Forged pistons will make a knocking sound until the car is warmed up also. Just a story... One time I cracked a piston and simply replaced it with a stocker, and it turned out my block had been previously bored to .020" over and it was slapping like mad, it was less audible after the car warmed up.... obviously I replaced it and it didn't slap anymore. :D
95619, RE: Knock when started
Posted by Madoc05, Jan-09-06 10:14 AM
Yes i did rebuild it with forged pistons. but it sounds more like a grinding then a knock
95627, RE: Knock when started
Posted by ForceFed420a, Jan-10-06 03:24 AM
Does the sound change when you put the clutch in?
95636, RE: Knock when started
Posted by sike, Jan-10-06 08:32 AM
Forged pistons WILL knock. Perhaps it sounds grindish due to imperfections on the cylinder walls, but I think that is a little far fetched. Did you have the cylinders honed?
95638, RE: Knock when started
Posted by Madoc05, Jan-10-06 08:52 AM
I left the car in the garage were it's warmer last night and then started it in the this morning to see if the noise continued. Well it has stopped so i guess that would just be the TOB disagreeing with the cold weather right?
95657, RE: Knock when started
Posted by sike, Jan-11-06 08:34 AM
Come to think of it, TOB noise is more of a grindish/rattle sound. When you start it cold, press the clutch pedal in and if it doesn't make the sound, that is your problem, no biggie.
96606, RE: Knock when started
Posted by Resol, Feb-23-06 01:18 PM
so this TOB .... mine does the same shit. Should i worry about it? Will it blow goin down the highway when i drive 1.5 hours to UTI every day?
96611, RE: Knock when started
Posted by 95_ESi_Person, Feb-23-06 05:45 PM
Originally posted by Resol
so this TOB .... mine does the same shit. Should i worry about it? Will it blow goin down the highway when i drive 1.5 hours to UTI every day?


mine rattles, always has... I've gone a few years with it rattling... it rattled before I had the trans rebuilt, and started after it was rebuilt because the trans shop guys are retarded.

If I can go that long like that and make 7 hour drives, you'll be fine.
96628, RE: Knock when started
Posted by Resol, Feb-24-06 02:52 PM
Thank you