Go back to previous topic
Forum namePerformance/Engine
Topic subjectWhine when decelerating?
Topic URLhttps://forums.2gnt.com/dcboard.php?az=show_topic&forum=i5&topic_id=80873
80873, Whine when decelerating?
Posted by ggaarryy, Sep-22-04 03:54 AM
97 eclipse spyder manual trans with 102k miles. Car runs fine but I have been noticed an unusual sound.

Basically, when I am in gear and take my foot off the gas peddle, there is a cyclical hum/whine that appears. At first I thought it was just something loose and rattling but when I put the shifter in neutral, the noise stops. The noise also isn't present when the clutch is depressed or I rev it in neutral.

Any ideas what is causing the noise and how to eliminate it?

Thanks
80876, RE: Whine when decelerating?
Posted by DJ420a, Sep-22-04 05:35 AM
Could be a worn throw out bearing??
80915, RE: Whine when decelerating?
Posted by ggaarryy, Sep-23-04 07:12 AM
thanks but am confused by this article I found on 'throw out bearings':

http://www.carcarecouncil.org/Manual_Transmission/throw-out_bearing.shtml

According to it, "The classic symptom of a worn throw-out bearing is a whirring or growling sound when applying the clutch pedal, which goes away when releasing the pedal".

In my case, it makes a noise when taking my foot off the gas, and not when the clutch is depressed. I feel no difference in the clutch, shifting or when changing gears compared to before the noise started.

Any other thoughts?
81004, RE: Whine when decelerating?
Posted by OldGuy, Sep-25-04 01:36 PM
Generally when any bearing is going bad, it will "Growl". The whining you are hearing is the wheels driving the gears in the tranny instead of the other way around. I hear it when I am doing about 15-20 and down-shift into 1st when stopping. If the noise is constant it is a different thing altogether. It sounds though that you are hearing something that is totally benign. Most every standard I have ever had I have heard the same nois. And believe me, if it was your throw out bearing you would know it. It can be the most God-awful sound but is ONLY apparent whaen the clutch pedal is depressed.
Ricky
81072, RE: Whine when decelerating?
Posted by ggaarryy, Sep-28-04 03:24 AM
thanks ricky. It's a noise i never heard before, but then again, perhaps i just wasn't looking for it.
81121, RE: Whine when decelerating?
Posted by SaberKhan, Sep-28-04 05:24 PM
Sounds like gear whine to me. There are two sides to a gear tooth, the drive side and the coast side. I'd say the coast side of your gears are worn.