Go back to previous topic
Forum namePerformance/Engine
Topic subjectShopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Topic URLhttps://forums.2gnt.com/dcboard.php?az=show_topic&forum=i5&topic_id=80010
80010, Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by Dont_need_8, Sep-02-04 01:19 PM
A local shop will bend me 2.25 pipe and put on a Magnaflow (12615) for 205.00? Good price or should I keep shopping.

The only drawback is they crush bend. Can someone please tell me if I will see a difference between crushed and mandrel, beside a 10th of a second in the quarter? Even one says that mandrel is way better but it doesn't seem to make that much difference to me unless you are trying to squeeze that last drop of power for a timed event.

AEM CAI
AFX Underdrive Pulley
17" Fondmetal 6500
Tokico Illuminas
Eibach Pro Kit Springs
Front Upper Strut Bar
Baer Track System
Greddy Header
80011, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by silvereclipse30, Sep-02-04 01:34 PM
I have an Tsudo N-1 catback(2.5 mandrel bent) that sounds badass with less then 1k on it that I'm selling(I'm sellin my car and gettin a WRX)......email, pm me, or hit me up on AIM bchsbballstar!!!!
80012, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by Dont_need_8, Sep-02-04 01:39 PM
I don't think the angle exhaust will work with my rear end. I also think 2.5 will kill my low end. Thanks though.

AEM CAI
AFX Underdrive Pulley
17" Fondmetal 6500
Tokico Illuminas
Eibach Pro Kit Springs
Front Upper Strut Bar
Baer Track System
Greddy Header
80013, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by jsupetran, Sep-02-04 02:41 PM
imho, just change the muffler since you are paying basically stock piping (and worse exhaust system); crush bent is a waste. Just change the muffler and save your self a 100.


-------jezreel
1998 GS with hrc stage 2, sfmu, ml, prokits, Greddy warning gauges: egt, boost gauge, and oil pressure, apexi tt, haydans tranny cooler, costum dp, groundwires, dynotune fp gauge. gst muff, turbo spoiler
Boostin since Aug 03.

nothing like driving with the windows down and the music low: i love hearing the turbo spool, swwwhhhttt!!!!
thanks for www.kaptainmyke.com for the sig hosting :thumbsup

80014, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by Dont_need_8, Sep-02-04 02:51 PM
Ok, anyone else have an opinion?

AEM CAI
AFX Underdrive Pulley
17" Fondmetal 6500
Tokico Illuminas
Eibach Pro Kit Springs
Front Upper Strut Bar
Baer Track System
Greddy Header
80024, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by silvereclipse30, Sep-02-04 05:42 PM
this one doesn't angle out.....and it didn't kill my low end???
80041, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by 420AYE, Sep-03-04 06:14 AM
double
80042, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by 420AYE, Sep-03-04 06:31 AM
Originally posted by Dont_need_8
Ok, anyone else have an opinion? AEM CAI AFX Underdrive Pulley 17" Fondmetal 6500 Tokico Illuminas Eibach Pro Kit Springs Front Upper Strut Bar Baer Track System Greddy Header


If your not going to accept opinions then don't even post you dusche. Go back to t00ners or dsmt4lk.
80025, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by Talontaxi, Sep-02-04 05:49 PM
If they use a crush bender get them to make you 2.5 piping. It'll be about the same flow a 2.25 mandrel bent and it won't kill your bottom end.
80026, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by Ducking_Fumbass, Sep-02-04 07:48 PM
Look... you already have a fucking exhaust that flows like a 2.25" mandrel. It's called factory piping. The GS-T muffler on the stock piping is more then enough for whatever you want to do with it, short of a crazy bastard-style all motor setup (Brian) or a turbocharged setup.

I wish people would fucking quit trying to reinvent the goddamned wheel. Another thing, if you ask whether or not the GS-T muffler fits, you didn't search. And if you don't search, I will have Gil fuck you through your shorts until you die of rectal bleeding. K?
80027, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by Ark, Sep-02-04 07:53 PM
Originally posted by Ducking_Fumbass
And if you don't search, I will have Gil fuck you through your shorts until you die of rectal bleeding. K?

The sheer thought of this makes me giggle like a little school girl. I miss Gil...
80030, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by Ducking_Fumbass, Sep-02-04 08:33 PM
You miss Gil? That makes one of us. Now that you mention it, I don't think that ANYONE misses Gil. Gil sucked more then Richard Simmons on a dick farm.

80032, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by silvereclipse30, Sep-02-04 09:24 PM
and stock doesn't flow like 2.25 mandrel!!!
80034, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by Ducking_Fumbass, Sep-03-04 12:43 AM
Stock is mandrel, with a 2.25" diameter. Most of the world measures pipe diameter by OD, not ID. Stock is more then 2" ID-wise, though, since the OD is 2.25", and the walls are not 1/8" thick. Until you SERIOUSLY increase your volumetric efficiency, you have no need for a larger pipe.
80035, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by Star Turbo Talon, Sep-03-04 01:19 AM
^^^^^^ he is correct....you guys need to measure your pipes before you argue. Factory pipe is 2.25 od which is the same gauge piep a muffler shop will use.

Terry

96 Eagle talon ESI
Greddy header - Greddy exhaust

97 Eclipse
Star Stage II - Boost/oil/EGT gauges - 3" custom DP/Apexi N1 3" exhaust - SFMU/return line - Apexi SAFC - Stage 2 6 puck Sprung hub MIBA clutch - Shortened shifter - Koni Yellows w/eibach prokit - Stillen Fr/Rr swaybars - ceramic intake - DEI Keyless entry alarm - Niche 17" Shoks

Waiting to be installed: HKS EVC IV, 450 Turbo injectors, GSX Front brakes (need rotors)

Mitchell on Demand copies available
80038, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by jsupetran, Sep-03-04 04:18 AM
What happened to Gil? Is he Gilee?


-------jezreel
1998 GS with hrc stage 2, sfmu, ml, prokits, Greddy warning gauges: egt, boost gauge, and oil pressure, apexi tt, haydans tranny cooler, costum dp, groundwires, dynotune fp gauge. gst muff, turbo spoiler
Boostin since Aug 03.

nothing like driving with the windows down and the music low: i love hearing the turbo spool, swwwhhhttt!!!!
thanks for www.kaptainmyke.com for the sig hosting :thumbsup

80059, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by silvereclipse30, Sep-03-04 09:42 AM
its crush bent!!!! thats not gonna flow like 2.25 mandrel!!!!!!!
80070, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by Michael_97RS, Sep-03-04 12:12 PM
Holy goat fucking ass-monkey.

Crush bent it the crap that actually folds against itself. The stock pipe is press bent and is at least smooth even though it ovals in the bends.

I'd rather keep press bent 2.25" stock piping than put on a 2.5" crush bent exhaust any day of the week and twice on Sunday.

I wouldn't put crush bend piping on a lawn mower, let alone my car.

Stay the hell away from crush bent pipe, it's crap.



Exile Racing Technologies: http://www.exileracing.com
So. All that's left, is... everything - Jesse James
80071, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by Dont_need_8, Sep-03-04 12:20 PM
Originally posted by 420AYE
If your not going to accept opinions then don't even post you dusche. Go back to t00ners or dsmt4lk.


I don't remember saying that I accepted or denied any opinion, from now on I will try and include you in all my decision making so you don't get fussy. I also think that I would like to have more than a couple of opinions before I run off and do anything. Both suggestions were good, the pictures of silvereclipse30's pipe looks like it angles out to the drivers side, he says it doesn't but it looked that way in the pictures. jsupetran also gave me a good idea except that I may have holes in my exhaust from rust. The GS-T exhaust is another option I considered. Yes, I know it fits thanks Ducking Fumbass for that jackass comment. I don't think dual tips will look good with the rear bumper I have. Finally your response of "Double" what is that in relation to? Are you saying they are charging me double what I should pay or are you seconding someone else opinion?

Concerning 2.25 vs 2.5, the person who will be doing the exhaust has 20+ years experience and he felt that crush bending really doesn't make a huge difference and that 2.5 could kill my low end. So I am weighing that against first hand experience with the 420a.

Why don't you take that bad attitude to tOOners or dsmt41k.
80073, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by DR1665, Sep-03-04 01:23 PM
Originally posted by Ducking_Fumbass
a crazy bastard-style all motor setup (Brian)


HEY! lmao. :P
80077, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by silvereclipse30, Sep-03-04 06:02 PM
SORRY MAN.......those pics r of the muffler I sold like a week ago.....I just put the catback on my car.....if u would like some pics thats cool just let me know and I'll take some.....and yes my old muffler did angle out!!!
80084, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by Green, Sep-04-04 06:49 AM
Covered many times

http://forums.2gnt.com/dcboard.php?az=show_topic&forum=5&topic_id=79837&mode=full
80099, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by Dont_need_8, Sep-04-04 11:49 AM
I know it has been covered and I know that everyone says mandrel is better. I also understand the science behind what makes it better. My question is how much better. Is it the difference of 1/100th of a sec in the quarter? A full second? No one can give real world terms only scientific data. I was also asking about a specific price for the work.

Anyways, I pm'ed silvereclipse30 to get some pictures of his setup. If you read this silvereclipse30, I also want to know if it goes over or under the rear crossmember?
80101, RE: Shopping for cat-back, is this a good deal?
Posted by Green, Sep-04-04 12:28 PM
I didn't know that there would be much of a difference between mandrel and crush bends until I saw first hand how important it was with my friend's wrx.
He had a custom cat back put in with larger than stock piping (crush) and free flow muffler. He put in an aftermarket boost controller and the motor started knocking after raising the boost by 1psi.
He then changed to a mandrel bent aftermarket cat-back and could turn up the boost 3psi without any problems.

Now, I know that his is a turbo'd car and we probably wouldn't run into that problem n/a, but it shows that there is a difference with the bends.