| Go back to previous topic |
| Forum name | Performance/Engine |
| Topic subject | this is becoming so much fun... tob was not the issue so lets play name that sound!!! |
| Topic URL | https://forums.2gnt.com/dcboard.php?az=show_topic&forum=i5&topic_id=105041 |
105041, this is becoming so much fun... tob was not the issue so lets play name that sound!!! Posted by Collente, Jul-04-07 07:00 AM
Well.. the TOB wasn't the root cause.
The background of this loud ass knocking noise: Replaced bearings (though nothing indicated they needed to be changed), no metal shavings, no smoke, TOB on backwards (fixed), no metal shaving in tranny as well.
Here it is: http://starvingstudents.org/car/car.wav
It's got to be rod knock.
Nick 97RS
|
105042, RE: this is becoming so much fun... tob was not the issue so lets play name that sound!!! Posted by edxmon, Jul-04-07 08:19 AM
It seems to only happen at rpms higher than 1-2k? Also it doesnt sound "consistent", more like some thing is loose in there and flies around randomly. Aside from that, I don't know what else to say.
|
105044, RE: this is becoming so much fun... tob was not the issue so lets play name that sound!!! Posted by Collente, Jul-04-07 09:18 AM
thx for the response man, sucks cause I dont expect anyone to know.. maybe an, ah HA! but thats just wishful thinking.
Nick 97RS
|
105045, RE: this is becoming so much fun... tob was not the issue so lets play name that sound!!! Posted by bullettdsm, Jul-04-07 10:10 AM
It's tough when you gotta listen on the computer but I don't hear any base sound like if it was rod rap. I suspected that at first but....kinda lots of treblish noise like it's in the bellhousing. You say you pulled the rod bearings and they were fine? No shavings when you pulled apart the tranny and block? It could be at the wrist pin area, but, again, usually more base type sound. Is it coming from the bellhousing area? Is anything hitting the flywheel/PP? It's a whole lot easier to listen to live. Why don't you stop over and I'll listen to it then :shrug
|
105047, RE: this is becoming so much fun... tob was not the issue so lets play name that sound!!! Posted by Styles., Jul-04-07 11:57 AM
check the cam caps and check the flywheel for a crack or lose bolt
|
105051, RE: this is becoming so much fun... tob was not the issue so lets play name that sound!!! Posted by Collente, Jul-04-07 12:39 PM
Thanks for the info on the rod knocking type sounds, I've never heard rod knock before but it just doesn't add up to be bearing pobs. I've checked the bellhousing and I thought for sure it the tob on backwards, but nope. Checked the valve components and rod caps and that's all fine.
It sounds like something is getting caught up and banging around. In the water lines? Hitting the water pump? Maybe i'll pull the lower rad pipe and check the teeth.
Nothing adds up. NO SHAVINGS ANYWHERE. It does heat up quite fast as well. I wonder if it is the water pump...
Nick 97RS
|
105052, RE: this is becoming so much fun... tob was not the issue so lets play name that sound!!! Posted by DR1665, Jul-04-07 01:05 PM
Lord almighty! What a horrible sound.
Have you taken apart the trans yet, Nick? When I lost my input shaft bearing in the tranny, I got a noise not too unlike that, although much less rapid. I was driving the car the day after we patched the bell housing from the clutch coming apart three days after a seven month delayed rebuild, so I wasn't really getting on it, but let me see if I can't get a video up...
EDIT: Here you go.
http://dr1665.com/misc/Dasiynoise.wmv
|
105054, RE: this is becoming so much fun... tob was not the issue so lets play name that sound!!! Posted by freelancefool, Jul-04-07 01:51 PM
All I am getting is a 404 error Driggs.
|
105059, RE: this is becoming so much fun... tob was not the issue so lets play name that sound!!! Posted by foggy45, Jul-04-07 06:21 PM
jesus that was painful :( have you gone around with a mechanics stethascope to try and pinpoint it? silly but anything hanging around the belts or any pullies? your cam gears look ok?
|
105064, RE: this is becoming so much fun... tob was not the issue so lets play name that sound!!! Posted by DarkOne, Jul-05-07 06:34 AM
Originally posted by foggy45 have you gone around with a mechanics stethascope to try and pinpoint it?
Quoted for truth. Mechanic's Stethescopes are invaluable in these kinds of situations.
|
105060, RE: this is becoming so much fun... tob was not the issue so lets play name that sound!!! Posted by DR1665, Jul-04-07 07:28 PM
Originally posted by freelancefool All I am getting is a 404 error Driggs.
My bad. Who woulda thought I typo'd the spelling of my own car's name back in 2005 and didn't catch it when I uploaded it to the site this afternoon. I fixed the link.
|
105065, RE: this is becoming so much fun... tob was not the issue so lets play name that sound!!! Posted by Keith2172, Jul-05-07 06:37 AM
What's your starter look like? Almost sounds like the gear got hung up or something. Meh, that's probably too far fetched to happen in a DSM.
|
105154, RE: this is becoming so much fun... tob was not the issue so lets play name that sound!!! Posted by Collente, Jul-11-07 08:04 AM
I re thread locked the flexplate to cluch bolts and the problem ceased. Fucker.... I wonder if the torque of the engine was pushing the clutch out towards the bellhousing? Maybe pushing it towards the engine under load which pushed the bolts back into the block causing the noise...
Thank for all the help and response guys. Least now I can feel good about the bearings ;)
Nick 97RS
|
105155, RE: this is becoming so much fun... tob was not the issue so lets play name that sound!!! Posted by DR1665, Jul-11-07 08:49 AM
Originally posted by Collente I re thread locked the flexplate to cluch bolts and the problem ceased. Oh man. You just dodged a major bullet right there, my friend. That's what leads to the damage seen in the following excessively huge pictures. (Remove the space between the P and G.)
1. Free-wheeling clutch became something of a circular saw, cutting a hole into the transmission. Scary as hell to have all your trans fluid drain out of the bellhousing onto your downpipe at 45mph and not be able to shift gears. http://az2gnt.net/DR1665/Daisy/NV-T350/bellhousingMod.JP G
2. Of the four Grade 10+ flexplate bolts, this was the best looking of them afterwards. http://az2gnt.net/DR1665/Daisy/NV-T350/flexBolt.JP G
This also happened to me on the third day after we got her running after seven months of downtime. Sad thing was, I think the shock to the transmission internals of that modular clutch going crazy on the input shaft lead to the input shaft bearing failing another three days later.
My transmission has never sounded the same. :P Fifth gear has a sort of whine to it when cruising. Right in that sweet spot between accelerating and decelerating. I suspect the whole thing will grenade one day, but who knows...
Glad to hear you're back on the road, Nick. :thumbsup
|
105156, RE: this is becoming so much fun... tob was not the issue so lets play name that sound!!! Posted by turbo8u, Jul-11-07 09:38 AM
good oil pressure?
|
105159, RE: this is becoming so much fun... tob was not the issue so lets play name that sound!!! Posted by edxmon, Jul-11-07 06:11 PM
Originally posted by DR1665Originally posted by Collente I re thread locked the flexplate to cluch bolts and the problem ceased. Oh man. You just dodged a major bullet right there, my friend. That's what leads to the damage seen in the following excessively huge pictures. (Remove the space between the P and G.) 1. Free-wheeling clutch became something of a circular saw, cutting a hole into the transmission. Scary as hell to have all your trans fluid drain out of the bellhousing onto your downpipe at 45mph and not be able to shift gears. http://az2gnt.net/DR1665/Daisy/NV-T350/bellhousingMod.JP G 2. Of the four Grade 10+ flexplate bolts, this was the best looking of them afterwards. http://az2gnt.net/DR1665/Daisy/NV-T350/flexBolt.JP G This also happened to me on the third day after we got her running after seven months of downtime. Sad thing was, I think the shock to the transmission internals of that modular clutch going crazy on the input shaft lead to the input shaft bearing failing another three days later. My transmission has never sounded the same. :P Fifth gear has a sort of whine to it when cruising. Right in that sweet spot between accelerating and decelerating. I suspect the whole thing will grenade one day, but who knows... Glad to hear you're back on the road, Nick. :thumbsup

:P
|
105160, RE: this is becoming so much fun... tob was not the issue so lets play name that sound!!! Posted by DR1665, Jul-11-07 07:56 PM
Originally posted by edxmon :P Funny!
|